You Had Me At Pizza

We had garlic pull apart bread, wings, Detroit style pizza (classic), and a signature meat lovers pizza. The wings and the classic were excellent. The Detroit style was good, but not great, a bit doughy. The pull apart was a disappointment, cold in the middle and the bread was dry (we did send it back and a new one came back warmer but still not heated fully through). Great service and a comfortable atmosphere.

We have had Take-out from You Had Me at Pizza a few times when we are in the area and it never disappoints. This time we ordered the Dill Pickle Pie, Detroit Classic, All About the Meat and the Garlic Bread/Knots with Cheese. The pizza was ready upon arrival and service was friendly. There are tables to dine in with dim lighting to set a cozy atmosphere. We will absolutely be ordering from here again!

My son's favorite pizza spot! He loves the pizza. I can't get enough of the pasta-less lasagna. My wife loves the wings and Cesar salad. Always a nice night for the family. Update: years later and this place is still super solid.

We tried You Had me at Pizza for the first time. We make excellent pizzas at home, but have to say we were blown away by the Bronx pizza. Hot and room temperature...both wonderful. Absolutely delicious and different from anything else we have made or had in a restaurant or takeout. The sauce, dough, meatballs... more than worth the extra cost to other local options. Partly because it's a very hearty pizza that has you filled before others. We ate less and the meal was really 2 meals for us. We love supporting local businesses. Truly awesome.

I had some really delicious pizza and chicken wings. I believe I got their Detroit style pizza, and their chicken wings tossed in their BBQ sauce & honey garlic. Gosh, the food was so delicious. The folks there were also super friendly and helpful! I would definitely order from here again when I’m back in Grimsby next time!