The Tangerine Tortoise

Best pizza I've had outside NYC. Still thinking about the salad too! Wonderful service, very comfortable and cozy setting. Felt like I was dining in someone's home, in the best way.

Mad respect to how they run things here. But the important thing: the pizza is great, with familiar and unique flavours. Crunchy crust with that floppy middle that holds well with a good fold. The toppings don’t overwhelm the dough, and each ingredient gets a chance to stand out. Had the pizza with hot honey, and the one with asiago. Big fan of both

Our first visit... amazing! Cute, cozy spot. The spinach salad was great and the hot pineapple pizza was incredible. Reasonably priced local beer and wine. Can't wait to go back.

This restaurant is definitely a gem, hiding within a mostly residential neighbourhood. With no outdoor signage, a limited menu and simple decor, Tangerine Tortoise did not disappoint. Their website clearly states that reservations are recommended and that walk ins are risky since they only make so much pizza dough. So to those who complained about that, learn to read. Staff were friendly and polite and made sure they were available if we needed anything. The spinach salad was simple but had a great taste. I had the Asiago prosciutto pizza and my husband had the Meatza well done. They were both perfect. The crust had an amazing taste and wasn’t heavy in my stomach. The toppings were fresh and delicious. The size of the pizza was enough to take home leftovers for breakfast the next day. We will definitely be back.

Been waiting a long time to try this place. Locally owned and operated. Stellar pizza. Seriously amazing quality pizza. The Asiago & Prosciutto will have you craving for more and curious about the others. Great service. Friendly staff. Comfortable atmosphere. Love the interior design. Clean facility. Clean washrooms. Pizza is made to order. Best you reserve yours or have a pre-order before arrival. No credit card surcharge. Prices are a little high for the portion.