The Pie Plate

Bought a few pies for a birthday. One was delicious. The other a wet soupy mess. Couldnt even serve it. Called the next day to speak with a manager, was supposed to call me . Never received a call.

We always order pies from the Pie Plate usually 3 or 4 at a time for every family holiday dinner plus birthdays . The last few times we have been disappointed in the pies .there is hardly any Whip cream and meringue on the pies and the fruit pies are sadly lacking filling and too much crust . At $30 per pie I expect better . So disappointing . I won’t be back

Honestly, great sandwiches and baked goods. Unfortunately, the service is not good. This is my second time here and both visits were met with bad service by the same woman. The staff working on the sandwich counter was clearly upset and was raising his voice towards the woman to help the older staff ringing us out. We asked for our sandwiches to go and it wasn't communicated. The woman had to bring it back to the kitchen to be wrapped. One of our friends sandwich was taking a very long time to be made so we started eating our food. Since we've been starving, when her sandwich arrived, she took a moment to take a bite and the woman comes over and asked in a very rude and annoyed manner.. "I thought you guys wanted it to go?" We just waited 20 minutes for sandwiches and watched service. You're choosing to work in service. Front of house. Be kind. Be nice. It's unfortunate that this bakery serves good food but the staff and quality of service deters customers from coming back.

Peach pastry was amazing😍 I don't know the official name but almost half peach was in the pastry. Since we loved it so much, we stopped by the next morning to bring back home. Unfortunately, it sounded like that was a random deal and they didn't make it again. Latte was good and beautiful, and the girl at the counter was sweet as well. Please make Peach pastries again. We may drive 3.5 hours from the U.S.!?

Absolutely loved our visit to The Pie Plate in Virgil — what a gem! From the moment we arrived, Lola’s warm and thoughtful service made us feel right at home. She welcomed us with a smile and a refreshing glass of cucumber water, which was the perfect touch on a summer day. The food was fantastic — the pepperoni pizza had a perfectly crisp crust and bold, savoury flavour. The salmon croissant sandwich was buttery, fresh, and beautifully balanced, and the quiche was light, creamy, and full of goodness. Every bite tasted homemade and full of care. The iced coffee was also a standout — smooth, bold, and refreshing without being too sweet. Between the cozy atmosphere, delicious food, and Lola’s incredible hospitality, it was one of the best stops we’ve made in Niagara. Highly recommend!