Pizzajerrys/Pete's Pizza
P

Pizzajerrys/Pete's Pizza

Free
3.8(5 reviews)
313 Merritt St, St. CatharinesListed 6 days ago
B BGoogle
November 20, 2025

Normally decent pizza but last few orders it’s been clear the pizza is old, crust tastes stale, texture is off, not fresh pizza at all. Have forgotten to give blue cheese with wings and the wings have been very dry. Will not be ordering from here moving forward. I have worked in a pizzeria back in the day and I know the difference between fresh spread dough and using day or two day old pizzas, they are definitely not using fresh, spread dough.

View on Google
JerryGoogle
October 18, 2025

My son brought a tray of pepperoni pizza last night. It was our first time trying this pizza. It was superb. Perfectly balanced ingredients and the crust was excellent, crispy and cooked to perfection. We will definitely be back!

View on Google
XotiicWCGoogle
September 30, 2025

The location is very interesting with plaques and a very cool atmosphere inside. The pizza is perfect with a balanced amount of sauce cheese and dough. I come here every time I am in the country!

View on Google
Jaikob HaywoodGoogle
June 19, 2025

Always a decent pizza. Not much for selection on toppings but everything tastes good. I've never hated a pizza here. Gluten free crust is very meh, I was told that the coliflower crust was better.

View on Google
Szilvia TakoGoogle
April 17, 2023

We just moved to StCatharines and trying every pizza place. First time order from this place through Skip. Cannot track order, because they manage their own delivery. Ordered 8 slice with 1 pound hot wings. ($43) The facts: Delivery was over an hour. Food was barely warm, wings less than a pound, pizza ok, nothing special. Taste good, but not the best. Overall: we tried, we ate, but isn't gonna be our pizza place.

View on Google
313 Merritt St, St. Catharines, Ontario, L2T 1K3

Claim this listing to manage it, respond to reviews, and add photos.

Sign In to Claim