Pizza di Nonna

*Update: after I left this review the owner replied and issued a refund, sent me a personal email to apologize, and gave me a gift card to give them a second chance. Way above and beyond the typical response and appreciated! I went ahead and ordered The Godfather, which was phenomenal and exceeded my original expectations. The crust is addicting! Amazing to see an owner who cares and delivers a quality product. Would definitely return ** Had high hopes but was very let down. Ordered the NY cheese pizza and it came very burnt. I don't mind a well done pizza, but this is too much. The cheese had no flavour or pull, crust like cardboard. For the price? Insane

Starting the new year the right way, and honestly, there’s no better way than with pizza from Pizza Di Nonna 🍕🔥 I went with the well done medium with Ezzo beef pepperoni, homemade sliced beef meatballs, finished with Dave’s hot honey drizzle—and wow. Every bite was next-level. Perfectly balanced, unreal flavour, and you can immediately tell this isn’t your average pizza. What really sets Pizza Di Nonna apart is what James is doing for his customers. The care, pride, and attention to detail he puts into every pie is obvious. Using top-tier ingredients imported directly from Italy makes a massive difference, and it shows in the taste, texture, and overall experience. I’m genuinely thankful for people like James who care deeply about quality and their community, and who refuse to cut corners. If you haven’t tried Pizza Di Nonna yet, do yourself a favour—this is what real pizza is supposed to be. Starting the year grateful, full, and already planning my next order. 👌🍕

This is the type of pizza you should travel for! And if you’ve seen my reviews, you know we actually do travel for food — so trust me when I say this is pizza worth going out of your way to try. Exceptional pizza, the best ingredients, fantastic flavour combinations, and an owner who truly cares about both the craft and his customers. You can taste it in every bite, especially in that perfectly crisp, crunchy, airy crust. We tried several different pizzas. The vodka pizza was incredibly tasty, but the star of the show was a pie topped with peaches, arugula, and just the right amount of heat from peppers — an unexpected combo that absolutely worked. Everything was exceptional, right down to the warm customer service and the owner sharing his story. You can feel the genuine love for the craft and the business. This is some of the best pizza in the area. Highly recommend. 🍕👌🏻

Best pizza in Grimsby, hands down! 🍕 We regularly order takeout from Pizza Di Nonna, and every single time they blow us away with their incredible ingredients that are all organic and delicious. During peach season, we tried their Spicy 🌶️ Peach 🍑 Pizza, and it was pure perfection — sweet, spicy, and absolutely unforgettable. Our all-time favourite, though, has to be the Texas Diet. The moment that box arrives, nobody in the house can keep their hands off it! If you’re looking for top-quality, flavour-packed pizza made with care, this is the place to go in Grimsby.

Ordered their Aloha Brisket pizza, and it was very good. A bit on the pricey side but well worth it IMHO. I have tried other "award winning" pizzas in Hamilton and this was better. Will definitely try their other flavors soon.