Craig's Cookies

Forget everything you thought you knew about cookies—Craig's Cookies are in a league of their own, and it's not just hype; it's a phenomenon baked in love, nostalgia, and stuffing! What makes them arguably the best in the world? It starts with the base recipe, passed down from Craig's Newfoundlander mother, delivering that perfect homemade, comforting texture. But the true magic is in the next-level mix-ins! They don't just use chocolate chips; they stuff the cookies with whole, glorious childhood treats like Mars Bars, Mini Eggs, Peanut Butter Cups, and even Pop Tarts! Every bite is an explosion of flavor and texture, gooey, rich, and perfectly balanced with a touch of necessary saltiness that keeps the sweetness from being overwhelming. Beyond the incredible product, the brand's heart is huge! Craig Pike, the founder, built the empire on principles of inclusivity, community, and joy, creating shops that feel like a warm, welcoming visit to your grandmother's kitchen. The sheer number of creative, rotating flavours—over 100 at one point—means there is always something new and exciting. They’ve successfully taken a simple concept and turned it into an unforgettable, community-focused experience. This is more than a cookie; it's a happy pink box of pure delight.

We stopped by Craig’s Cookies in Niagara-on-the-Lake and really enjoyed it. We picked up a half dozen cookies, and each one had great flavour — soft, rich, and made with noticeable care. The shop has a fun, welcoming feel, and the staff were friendly and patient while we chose our mix. A nice stop while walking around downtown NOTL, especially if you’re in the mood for something sweet.

Absolutely delicious cookies and great innovative selection of flavors. 10X better than Crumbl. Was happy to discover there’s so many locations across the GTA. Very cute little box of cookies, $18 for 6 nice size cookies. The Skor was absolutely delicious. And a Glossettes Peanut cookie was pretty cool.

Craig’s Cookies has an amazing selection of cookies—it’s hard to choose just one! We picked up half a dozen, and every single one was absolutely delicious. They also offer cold drinks, which pair perfectly with the sweet treats. The bakery itself is on the smaller side, but it has a cozy and welcoming atmosphere. It wasn’t too busy when we went; from the moment I walked in to placing my order and walking out. If you’re looking for a quick, tasty treat and a friendly vibe, Craig’s Cookies is definitely worth a visit! Co

They have a large selection of cookies, every candy and sweet treat that you can think of, is probably baked into one of these cookies. Once you walk in, they do have a fridge to the right of the entrance where you can purchase cold drinks and small bags of chips, if desired. The bakery itself is a relatively smaller place, but the atmosphere is warm and welcoming. It wasn’t relatively busy, from the moment I walked in to purchasing my order and leaving, it was a 2-5 minute period. The lady who worked there was incredibly friendly and nice, she made sure I had what I wanted.